Supply chains and digital transformation: How Manutan rebuilt its systems and strategy
Executive summary: Distributing giant Manutan moved from a reactive customer engagement strategy to a proactive approach through going cloud-native. While the process had various roadblocks, the sense of engagement and community was key. Xavier Laurent, director of value added services at Manutan, has ‘lived the journey of transformation’ over the past 10 years and discusses how the company meets customer demand in the digital economy through becoming more agile in its engagements, as well as combining technological and cultural innovation
Longread We live in a time of disruption, where brand names and legacy businesses cannot rest on their laurels due to increasingly affordable technologies. The supply chain demands faster, most cost-effective processes leading to the panacea of frictionless engagement.
Transformation sounds exciting and positive – but often the barrier of change and threat of the unknown deter the necessary action, speed and commitment needed to achieve the promised land. We live in a time where technology enables what 10 years ago was either impossible or cost prohibitive for all bar the few. Cloud, IoT, AI, big data, VR, drones and more are all changing the living environment around us – and with this, the customer expectation and demand also changes.
It is time to take stock of what is achievable, the importance of starting the journey now, and to appraise the impact of doing nothing. The gain is far greater than the pain to get there; are you ready to value your future and make the first step? Distributing giant Manutan is an example of a legacy firm which has transformed to say relevant – and here they bring us the realities from the story of their journey.
The time to transform is now
Having been in the cloud sector for more than 13 years, I have watched as it has gone from infant, to child – initially crawling past those holding onto legacy approaches and fearing the cloud – through to walking, and now starting to jog. The full sprint is still ahead of us as we witness the acceleration of innovative and disruptive use cases being brought to market.
We are finally seeing more cloud advocates in the room than cloud doubters and resisters, and seeing enough momentum to view cloud and its cohorts of big data, AI and IoT push past the human barriers. Technology used to divide the market, with solutions offering ‘enterprise’ functions requiring associated costly infrastructure and complex deployment. For example, you would find an application that required numerous high-end servers or mini-computers to run it, database servers and complex installations which quickly raised the entry price bar to a level that distanced them from the average firm. The ‘have nots’ who could not afford such elite offerings were relegated to using different products often lacking key functions, or the backing of vendors large enough to deliver innovation and as many enhancement updates.
This technology hindering went on for many years until the disruptive entrance of true cloud offerings. With cloud, we started to witness application delivery, through multi-tenancy efficiencies, which flattened the market, making the commercials for a 5000- or 5-user license viable for both respective companies. The smaller firm, for the first time, was able to choose the same class offering as the large enterprise brand name, without the high upfront investment cost barriers. Cloud has enabled new innovative firms to revitalise many areas of the software market, delivering innovation, more function, and fresher user experiences that befit our mobile, Internet-based world. Legacy vendors have therefore been forced to revitalise their offerings, re-platform and transform them to a more flexible technical and commercial model, all to the benefit of their employees, customers and business partners in the supply chain.
Supply chains have long relied on traditional manual processes, heavy lifting, and inefficient data insights into where to tune and gain competitive advantage. Proven cloud technology is here today to transform this effectively and affordably; it may seem obvious to take the first steps to making this happen, but many embroiled in the old way are hampered by legacy thoughts and perceived barriers of the journey ahead and hence take no action. With the disruption happening across industries right now, even a successfully performing company can quickly turn sour should a competitor change the game on them. Today, a breadth of companies are undertaking this transformational journey and are on their way to surprising competitors, as they come out of the gate refreshed and supercharged.
A digital transformation success story
I recently had the pleasure to gain great real-world insight with the challenges and market benefits this transformation brings through conversations with both SAP Ariba and Xavier Laurent, director of value added services at Manutan, who has lived the journey of transformation over the past 10 years.
Digital transformation is not as easy as the words and hype written about it may make it seem. It is a combination of change involving people, process and technology and needing the business gains to visibly outweigh the losses and pain to drive people to make it happen.
Deferring digitisation is easy when realisation of the work involved comes to light. No wonder so many default to the status quo, delaying projects and wading on painfully with existing systems and methods
Manutan has a 50-year legacy of B2B distance selling, from original paper catalogue through to being an innovator in the initial days of the web, through to dynamic cloud-based digitisation of the B2B supply chain. Originating in distance selling of lower priced transactional products, higher cost of sales through manual engagements were palatable in the early days where competition was less stringent, and margins were more supporting. Manutan was one of the first to identify the importance of the web, going back 15 years; its first foray into digitisation. This undoubtedly made the decision to digitise the supply chain process further an easier one than for many firms.
Noticing a pressure from customers looking for an easier, most cost-effective relationship, it was the last four to five years which took the change further as Manutan invested in an e-procurement team focused on a portfolio of customers. Combining this with a digitisation of systems and procurement has driven a very positive increase of clients 10% ahead of industry averages – the sort of outcome any business will happily accept.
To achieve the level of supply chain digitisation and client positivity was not simply a case of technology, but a combination of smart decisions, investing and resourcing in the right places. For example, Manutan has 10 people (purchase consultants) in charge of building KPIs around productivity, speed, and accuracy of customer projects. Whilst people and resources help, without the new cloud systems to empower them, the successful gains being recognised would not have been as great.
The drivers and challenges
One of the initial challenges was that spend from ‘class C’ customers typically only represented 5% of their acquisition process. Hence it was not the focal point for gains. Purchase directors seeing low value transactions in class C had not focused in this area. Despite there being a volume of orders with small value items across the business, the true value gain that could be recognised here was hidden – they could not see the wood for the trees. However, once class A and B had been optimised fully and customers had reached this maturity in their lifecycle, they quickly realised that whilst with class A, and to a degree class B, purchases there was some easy wins in simple price savings, with class C price savings were not going to be as easy to achieve, as with lower cost items there was less to play with.
The gains here are to be made from process improvements; reducing supplier breadth, management/removal of rogue purchases, lowering supplier management costs and, as much as possible, automating and digitising the process. Through adoption of effective tools – in this case SAP Ariba – it is a clear benefit to improve productivity on class C purchases and thus gain competitive advantage.
With class C purchases typically having a wider spread and less attention, the challenge is even greater in procurement to collate, structure and analyse related data in order to ratify and streamline purchasing. Reports show that up to 80% of company data is unstructured, and thus not delivering business insight in order to drive value. It is unsurprising then that only 8% of companies currently believe that they have effective class C purchase process management.
On class C products seeking to make the gains from cost reduction on unit pricing may seem obvious, but this can also be counter-productive. The impact of a lower cost supplier can be a less reliable service; costly errors and longer lead times, with knock-on effects on your supply chain and larger orders and relationships, where the class C itself is not the key but contributing to the whole for the customer’s output. Focusing on streamlining inventory, removing silos, and improving forecasting of demand, can all enable a gain across the chain.
Laurent’s focus at Manutan, of reducing supply chain costs for class C transactional products and helping customers gain, is not an uncommon need. The drive was to deliver an application architecture that helped customers by digitising everything possible including product visibility, workflows, new orders, delivery, and invoicing. Through time spent understanding customer purchase processes and challenges with the manual approach to class C, Manutan has achieved a three times reduction on overall cost for its customers, both raising the relationship bar whilst embellishing customer loyalty, competitive advantage, and greater growth of revenues. Some of this has come from the attitude in the business to change and make it happen, with added empowerment from the flexibility of the Ariba platform which handles the most transactions in the Manutan group today.
The use of SAP Ariba as an enabling platform for these gains is now enabling Manutan to address new challenges from customers and deliver solutions in hours and not weeks – a ‘why would the customer go elsewhere?’ advantage. Through the automation and efficiencies gained, customers are now able to see the logic of reducing suppliers to one that can deliver better cost management across product lines and overall consolidation.
Meeting customer demands in the digital economy
Manutan is driven to being known as an expert in its field, with a reputation for reliability, speed, and maturity. To have maintained this and grown above industry averages is an accolade in itself. Xavier cites SPA Ariba combined with the attitude of its team as the gateway to adding flexibility and agility to the Manutan mantras. Transformation as market needs and trends demand is not easy and requires a ‘can do’ and ‘take action’ approach, this being the hindrance of many larger organisations.
One unforeseen benefit of going through a digital transformation project is that it often drives peripheral insights and discussions that identify and drive additional positive changes to the business
Manutan did have the advantage that it was an early adopter of the web and the basics of e-procurement, but it has had to maintain this willingness to early adopt. The company historically had taken a reactive best efforts approach to meeting customer needs, as many will recognise in their own businesses. This progressed to building a team incorporating service account managers and purchase consultants in charge of partnering with customers in the same language, and then conduiting the client’s needs internally to Manutan divisions such as IT, supply chain, and finance.
Part of the process change identified meant that Manutan, on top of the technology changes, needed to become more agile in its people engagements. This meant being able to react quickly in an opportunistic mode; no blocking of requests from customers due to corporate lethargy or systems, but embracing them with the knowledge that Manutan’s systems and culture would support this approach.
This now allows long term projects to continue and be managed effectively, but enables fast responses to short-term customer needs ahead of these projects. Manutan empowers all staff to speak directly with clients. No more misinterpretations as an account manager takes their interpretation of a customer’s needs to IT; IT directly speaks with and engages the client, delivering faster outcomes and a greater customer experience for the expertise they access. Laurent reports this has driven a greater acceptance in the business of the new technologies and systems, empowerment to staff from top down, and a great level of customer partnership.
As Laurent talks, you can feel the enthusiasm he has for what the business has achieved, and the excitement for what is yet to come. His words iterate what I have heard from many – that it is no easy task to bridge the gap between old and new, to utilise the amazing technologies available today to deliver what today’s customer gravitates towards. Deferring digitisation is easy when realisation of the work involved comes to light; mapping out processes, engaging test customers, internal workshops, sometimes changing people’s roles and responsibilities, if not their long-held processes. A large action list of challenging activities appears at the outset, and this is before technology selection and implementation even rears its head. No wonder many default to the status quo, delaying projects and wading on painfully with existing systems and methods.
However, as Manutan perfectly illustrates, once you step out over the chasm, momentum gains and you quickly find yourself progressing on the journey with people on board, supporting the destination, and embracing the steps to get there.
Facing up to the change process
The change process should still not be underestimated. Laurent explained that there were still cultural barriers to overcome before they achieved today’s market-changing delivery model. Both sides of the coin needed education and mentoring into the new world; purchase directors and decision makers were not aware of the technology approach Manutan wanted to deliver, and salespeople did not initially appreciate the opportunity the technology presented. Sales was familiar with talking to procurement about price and process, but not with the capabilities of e-procurement to change the game and relationship. Throughout the process the organisation engaged its staff. Right from the outset, employees were involved and not isolated from what was going on; they felt they were part of a solution Manutan was moving towards, and remained heavily involved from start to finish.
I asked Laurent what had been learned from the change process – what had to be overcome and, with hindsight, what would have been done differently? The unsurprising conclusion, to me at least, was that it took longer than expected to move from a project-based organisation to an agile one. The historical culture was one of working in a slower moving, process-barriered market, one where technology was the remit of IT and not something all in the business should embrace at an innovative pace. New staff entered and helped with a mindset of accepting the change journey was underway and a positive thing.
Laurent’s passion for the new culture as a veteran is clear; having held multiple roles himself, he cites the difference has not only been the technology platform and the capabilities it has given, but also the validation from board down of the importance of digital and innovation to the business and its customers.
From the journey, other improvements were identified, such as the already mentioned siloing of engagement with the customer relationship manager. Laurent identified that this had gone on for too many years due to an ‘always being done that way’ outlook, and that the transformation process encouraged a look across the business at what could be improved. One unforeseen benefit of going through a digital transformation project is that it often drives peripheral insights and discussions that, indirect to the defined project, identify and drive additional positive changes to the business.
The journey’s path
Laurent was also clear to point out that along the journey there were wrong turns, bumps in the road, breakdowns, and a few accidents. Importantly, the team and business remained focused on the outcome and belief of the positive. They stayed resilient and determined throughout the process and drove the same downwards to their teams. Through this, Laurent reported the incredible team passion, excitement and agility he witnesses each day that digitisation has provided to the Manutan community.
Where businesses have already achieved a true fundamental transformation, they are usually eager to progress to the next
The outputs from the journey that Manutan as an organisation and the people, such as Laurent, have been on, is clear. Customers are better off; accuracy, speed, flexibility, effectiveness and cost reduction have all become mantras familiar to Manutan’s base, as has a ‘Manutan can do’ attitude. The business has gained market share, lowered return rates and achieved customer infusion of the phrase ‘love buying through us.’ KPIs have become more measurable and meaningful and improved both internally and externally to its customers. Manutan salespeople are gaining new clients through the ability to deliver valuable and contextual insights into the savings they can make, using customers’ real data, analysing the true cost of buying from Manutan, and providing a digital procurement illustration.
The cultural change has been an important one to support the changes the technology has enabled. A clear empowerment of staff to be responsible and the freedom to say yes or no to clients was driven across the business. This was described as the ‘007 license’ by Laurent; the license to find a solution for your client. Laurent’s voice was energised when he spoke, as a long-timer, of the ‘free’ feeling, supported by the organisation to be allowed to try and fail and challenge the status quo; to be different, to go faster, taking risks with the aim to create opportunity and be inventive. Much of this has been brought about by the underlying SAP Ariba platform that bridges Manutan more closely with its customers.
The next stage of the journey
With all the great upsides for Manutan, what is left? The focus has been on the downward supply chain, so by utilising a similar process of appraisal and alignment to the power of SAP Ariba, Manutan sees great opportunities to improve its upward supply chain, enabling greater efficiencies through even speedier delivery through approaches such as drop shipments. The delivery thus far has focused on the B2C channels, so B2B is also wide open to be transformed using a similar approach.
Manutan is now progressing on its continued journey and the strength that SAP Ariba has enabled allows the growth into other geographic regions. Laurent explained to me that the ideal is to build a ‘rinse and repeat’ model, one that will enable them to go faster as they enter new markets and drive even greater growth and competitive differentiation.
The key, however, is that the ‘better customer experience’ that SAP Ariba has enabled Manutan to deliver is continued through anything it does. While Ariba is at its foundation a technology, to Manutan it has gone far beyond this to a true business partnership for mutual gain; a transformational enabler.
There are still areas where much more could be done, Laurent explained, but from the experience and outcome already gained you can feel that Manutan does not fear entering a new process of change or innovation. I often engage with businesses and find where they have already achieved a true fundamental transformation, that they are eager to progress to the next. From Laurent’s pragmatic and transparent sharing, it is easy to see the strength that the platform has given Manutan, its team, and its customers, making business happen in the way customers want it to happen.
Manutan has aspirations to leverage AI capabilities. For example, where a client or prospect issues a large multi-thousand catalogue tender there is still a time consuming, manual and error-risk process to undertake. Being able to automate this for speedier response, with greater accuracy and reduced effort, would gain competitive advantage. There is also aspiration and plans to increase the catalogue size exponentially and this has impact on the marketplace; documentation needs, manuals, photography and support, which only becomes possible through utilisation and expansion of smart technology and increased digitisation.
Getting yourself involved
Industry’s wheel keeps on turning – and it is turning faster than ever before in history. We are seeing new goliaths seemingly born overnight, and legacy brand names failing at every turn. Sitting on your laurels and avoiding what looks like a potholed road is a dangerous option to take in lieu of doing nothing and not embarking on the journey.
If you have a supply chain where you have not optimised the procurement process and done all you can to engage with suppliers and customers, the time is now. There is no simple panacea switch to jump to the other side; how much pain you must go through will vary, but not doing anything has a far more painful outcome and risk waiting for you along the path. However an increasing number of firms, as Manutan for one has demonstrated, are showing that the only way to truly tap into effective supplier and spend management today is to adopt a cloud-native approach and leverage it to transform not only your tech, but as a conduit for positive effect on people and processes.
By making the change you will benefit both your own business, through a combination of efficiencies and consistencies helping to remove ‘rogue buying’ and gaining competitive advantages, and that of your customers in reducing their operational buying costs. Engagement becomes easier – and a pleasure.
Interested in hearing industry leaders discuss subjects like this and sharing their experiences and use-cases? Attend the Cyber Security & Cloud Expo World Series with upcoming events in Silicon Valley, London and Amsterdam to learn more.
- » IT operations in 2020: Five things to prepare for – from AIOps to multi-cloud and more
- » How the energy industry is embracing cloud computing: Three key areas of success
- » Microsoft and Reliance Jio team up in 10-year cloud deal to ‘transform Indian economy and society’
- » Capital One confirms data breach, cites cloudy approach as key to swift resolution
- » Why it's time to make continuous cloud security part of your developer journey